The End of 'Best'
Why ranking is losing power.
Welcome to Issue No. 016 of Sojourn. An independent publication delivering strategic interpretation for leaders shaping the future of travel and hospitality.
I’ve been noticing this in my own travel decisions. I’ll open a ranked list, scroll through the top ten, and feel nothing. Not because the properties aren’t good. Because ‘best’ doesn’t tell me anything about whether it’s right for me.
Interpretation: For decades, hospitality organized itself around a single question: what is the best option available? Best was defined by ratings, reviews, awards, and rankings. Platforms were built to surface it. Travelers were trained to seek it. That logic is weakening. Not because quality stopped mattering, but because ‘best’ was always a proxy for a harder question: does this place fit who I am right now? For a long time, the shortcut worked. Now it doesn’t. Travelers are more identity-aware, more fatigued by volume, and more attuned to the difference between a highly rated stay and one that actually felt right.
There’s a word that keeps coming up when people describe their best travel experiences. Not ‘impressive’. Not ‘luxurious’. Right. It felt ‘right’. That word is doing a lot of structural work these days.
What’s replacing ranking: The shift isn’t from ranking to nothing. It’s from ranking to recognition. When a brand has a clear enough identity, travelers don’t need to compare because they recognize it as theirs, or they don’t. That recognition bypasses the comparison process almost entirely. You can see this in how some properties have built devoted audiences without ever topping a major list. And in how some award-winning hotels struggle to convert attention into return visits. The ranking got them seen. The identity determined whether anyone came back.
What this means for brands: A hotel competing primarily on ranking is renting its visibility. Rankings change. Algorithms shift. But a brand with a clear, legible identity isn’t asking to be chosen over alternatives, it’s asking to be recognized by the right people. Recognized brands don’t need to be ranked first to be chosen first.
Clarity isn’t just aesthetically pleasing. It’s structurally protective. I think this is one of the most underestimated advantages in hospitality right now.
Bottom line: ‘Best’ was always a stand-in for ‘right’. As today’s travelers get better at knowing the difference, the brands that hold their ground won’t be the ones with the most stars. They’ll be the ones that are the most legible to the right people, at the right moment.
Have you noticed this shift in how you or your guests make decisions? I’d genuinely like to hear what you’re seeing on the ground.
The paid edition is where the analysis gets structural. If that's the conversation you want to be in, join here.